Supreme Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Supreme, nestled in the heart of West Seattle at 4521 California Ave SW. This trendy eatery serves up an impressive array of delicious pizzas by the slice, perfect for a quick snack or a leisurely evening out. With a chill bar atmosphere, Supreme stands out as a 21-and-over venue, making it a fantastic choice for date nights or gatherings with friends.

Highlighted by rave reviews, the menu showcases crave-worthy options like the custom goat cheese Detroit-style pizza, ensuring every bite is memorable. Guests have praised the friendly and accommodating staff, who enhance the welcoming vibe with exceptional service. Beyond pizzas, the beverage selection is thoughtfully curated, featuring frozen cocktails and classic drinks to enjoy while diving into nostalgic arcade games.

Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Supreme is a must-try spot that blends delicious food with a fun, laid-back environment.

Shareable

Scallion Garlic Knots

Tomato Sauce and Cheese Sauce.

US$11.00

Cheesy Bread (2pcs)

So cheesy, so crispy. Comes with ranch and marinara.

US$11.00

Lemon-Pepper Wings

served with celery sticks, ranch dressing

US$18.70

Caesar Salad

Romaine, parmesan, anchovy dressing, and brioche croutons..

US$15.15

Chicory Chop Salad

chicories, cherry tomatoes, olives, fresh mozzarella, cherry bomb peppers, artichokes, sweet onion, basil, mustard dressing.

US$14.85

Slice Veggie Supreme

Marinara, aged mozzarella, mushroom, green bell pepper, black olives, sweet onion, artichoke hearts, and provolone.

US$5.49

Slice Supreme

marinara, aged mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, salami, mushrooms, roasted green peppers, and black olives.

US$5.49

Slice Pepperoni

Twice the pepperoni and oregano.

US$5.49

Slice Detroit Square

Meat lovers - marinara, aged mozzarella, pepperoni, salami, broken meatball, and bacon.

US$5.69

Slice Cheese

Aged mozzarella, fresh whole milk mozzarella, garlic, and basil.

US$4.79

Pizza (Slices)

Sauces

Cheese Sauce

House made cheese sauce with a blend of aged mozzarella, fontina and provolone cheese

US$2.10

Marinara Sauce

US$1.25

Gorgonzola Dressing

House made gorgonzola dressing

US$2.00

Ranch

House made ranch

US$1.25

BBQ Sauce

House made bbq sauce

US$1.25

Cesar

House made Cesar dressing

US$1.75

The Jabroni Pie

Pesto, artichoke, feta, and arugula.

US$37.68

Ric And Morty Pie

Mortadella, ricotta, fontina, and black pepper.

US$48.40

Blanco Pie

Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, garlic, and seasoned heavy cream.

US$37.68

Mushroom Pie

Aged Mozzarella, Fontina, Thyme, Mushroom.

US$40.15

Potato Pie

Yukon gold potatoes, sweet onion, goat cheese, arugula, and thyme.

US$37.68

Pizza (Whole Pies - White)

Pizza (Whole Pies - Red)

Detroit Square Meat Lovers Pie

Marinara, aged mozzarella, pepperoni, salami, broken meatball, and bacon.

US$33.49

Oh, You're Sooo Hawaiian Pie

Portuguese sausage, pineapple, and jalapeno.

US$31.59

The Reaper Pie (Hot! Hot! Hot!)

Spicy coppa, ricotta, ghost chili, and Carolina reaper chili.

US$32.59

Double Pepperoni Pie

Twice the Pepperoni and Oregano.

US$31.59

BBQ Chicken Pie

BBQ sauce, roasted chicken, bacon, red onion, cilantro, and gorgonzola.

US$32.59

Bomb As Sausage Pie

Italian sausage, cherry bomb peppers, Swiss chard, and ricotta.

US$31.59

Supreme Pie

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, salami, mushrooms, roasted green peppers, and black olives.

US$33.49

Big Banger Pie

Italian sausage, mozzarella, garlic, and provolone.

US$31.59

Broken Meatball Pie

Spaghetti noodles, fresh mozzarella, basil, parmesan, and garlic.

US$29.19

Smokehouse Salami Pie

Green olives, pepperoncini, and provolone.

US$31.59

Veggie Supreme Pie

marinara, aged mozzarella, mushroom, green bell pepper, black olives, sweet onion, artichoke hearts, and provolone.

US$32.59

Double Cheese Pie

Aged mozzarella, fresh whole milk mozzarella, garlic, and basil.

US$28.49

Pepperoni

US$37.68

Cheese

aged mozzarella, garlic, basil

US$34.45

Build Your Own Pie

US$25.48

Pizza (Whole Pies - BYO)

Sides

Cheesy Bread (2pcs)

So cheesy, so crispy. Comes with ranch and marinara.

US$7.69

Chicory Chop Salad

Chicories, cherry tomatoes, olives, fresh mozzarella, pepperoncini, stone ground mustard dressing, and basil.

US$10.09

Caesar Salad

Romaine, parmesan, anchovy dressing, and brioche croutons..

US$9.59

Scallion Garlic Knots

Tomato Sauce and Cheese Sauce.

US$8.69

Marinara Sauce (2 Oz)

Side of house-made marinara sauce.

US$0.99

Lemon-Pepper Wings

Served with celery sticks and ranch dressing.

US$10.09

Bag

US$0.09

Ranch (2 Oz)

Side of house-made ranch.

US$0.99

Full Tilt Ice Cream (One Pint)

Mudhoney: honey-cinnamon ice cream with a fudge swirl.

US$8.69

Ice Cream Sandwich

US$1.49

Dessert

Beverages (N/A Beverage)

Soda Cans

US$2.08

¡Taco! Pie

¡TACO! Ground taco beef, cheddar cheese, green bell peppers, jalapenos, tapatio hot sauce, doritos dust, and lime sour cream.

US$31.59

Slice Taco!

¡TACO! Ground taco beef, cheddar cheese, green bell peppers, jalapenos, tapatio hot sauce, doritos dust, and lime sour cream.

US$5.49

Tuesdays!

Mondays!

Slice Radicchio

Seasoned heavy cream, aged mozzarella, radicchio, sweet onion, and goat cheese.

US$31.59

Radicchio Pie (Monday Special)

Seasoned heavy cream, aged mozzarella, radicchio, sweet onion, and goat cheese.

US$31.59

Slice Seattle Dog

Mozzarella, louisiana hot sausage, cream cheese jalapeno, and onions, topped with sriracha.

US$5.49

The Seattle Dog Pizza Pie

Mozzarella, Louisiana hot sausage, and cream cheese jalapeno, onions, topped with sriracha.

US$31.59

Saturdays!